Hamilton County Prosecutor Connie Pillich announces sentence for defendant in Lego theft scheme
Hamilton County Prosecutor Connie Pillich announces sentence for defendant in Lego theft scheme
Hamilton County Common Pleas Court Judge Virginia Tallent today sentenced James Bird to 3 – 4.5 years in prison for masterminding a reselling theft scheme. Bird, owner and operator of Paper Street Trading Company in Norwood, pleaded guilty in September to receiving stolen property, a third-degree felony, and telecommunications fraud, a second-degree felony.
Bird, 47, of Elsmere, Ky., operated a fencing business beginning in 2020, purchasing stolen merchandise and over-the-counter health care products from known boosters at prices far below market value. The stolen goods included LEGOs, medications, health care products and other merchandise taken from retailers including Kroger, Walmart, Target, TJ Maxx, Walgreens and Meijer.
The boosters frequently visited Bird’s business, sometimes daily, with large quantities of stolen merchandise. Bird made no effort to verify that the merchandise was legitimately obtained. He used eBay and PayPal to facilitate purchases and resell the stolen goods for profit.
Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office investigators recovered more than $158,000 in stolen merchandise during a February 2024 search of the business. An analysis of Bird’s electronic transactions identified more than $926,000 in transactions involving merchandise commonly stolen by retail boosters.
“James Bird didn’t simply steal from major retailers. He built a business around stolen merchandise and exploited people struggling with drug addiction, using their addiction to fuel his operation by encouraging their shoplifting,” said Hamilton County Prosecutor Connie Pillich.
“The impact goes far beyond the stores themselves. Retail theft drives up operating costs, and those costs are ultimately passed along to consumers through higher prices. Hardworking families end up paying for this kind of criminal enterprise. This sentence sends a clear message that those who organize, encourage and profit from retail theft will be held accountable.”
Co-defendant Travis Daniels, an employee of the store, will be sentenced Thursday on a charge of receiving stolen property.



